Best All-Time “Under 24” MLB Post-Season Lineup

Cubs1 560x218Consider this scenario for a second. You’re a Chicago Cubs fan and your team is sitting in 3rd place in the National League Central division behind two of the best teams in baseball, the St.Louis Cardinals and Pittsburgh Pirates on July 26th, 2015.

The Cubs finish the season 97-65 (46-19 after July 26th), in 3rd place in the NL Central while still holding the 3rd best overall record in baseball. They take out the Pirates in a one game playoff to advance to the National League Divisional Series against the St.Louis Cardinals, who just so happen to own the best record in baseball. But with an amazing roster of young talented future stars, the Cubs defeat the Cardinals and move onto the NLCS. They did it with 7 players under 25 years of age (three of them under 22).

The Cubs were not the only MLB team in the post-season this year to unleash the future of baseball. The Astros, Mets, Rangers, Pirates, and even the Cardinals gave us all hope for the future of the sport.

Jeter 560x219

If you were worried about baseball now that Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera retired, don’t be. This youth movement is bringing a whole new fan base to the sport along with fans in the stands. They are making the game fun again.

Let’s take a journey back over the past 100 years to put together the best MLB Post-Season Lineup with the only stipulation being that every player must be under 24 years of age the year they were in the playoffs.

(Statistics Updated as of 10/19)

C – Kyle Schwarber, Cubs (2015)

Kyle Schwarber 560x315

The 2015 playoffs are still going as we speak, however, Kyle Schwarber is doing something no one expected he would be doing at 22 years old. He is taking advantage of each and every at bat of the postseason and has put up some insane numbers based on age, experience, and how many playoff games he has played in his career.

  • Age: 22 Years Old
  • Games: 7
  • Batting Avg: .381
  • On-Base Pct: .435
  • Slugging Pct: .952
  • Hits: 8
  • Home Runs: 4
  • RBIs: 6
  • Runs: 5

1B – Albert Pujols, Cardinals (2004)

pujols 560x311

When the Cardinals defeated the Houston Astros in 7 games in 2004, it wasn’t easy. It was one of the best postseason series of all time but it took a toll on the players and especially Albert Pujols. His numbers were ridiculous and he did everything imaginable for that team but the Red Sox swept them 4-0 in the World Series. As a young man, this was the moment everyone realized he was going to be amazing.

  • Age: 24 Years Old
  • Games: 15
  • Batting Avg: .414
  • On-Base Pct: .493
  • Slugging Pct: .793
  • Hits: 24
  • Home Runs: 6
  • RBIs: 14
  • Runs: 15
  • Walks: 8

2B – Roberto Alomar, Blue Jays (1992)

Roberto Alomar 560x388

During the 1992 World Series, Roberto Alomar hit a single in the top of the 11th of Game 6 to start a rally that scored two runs and secured the Blue Jays their first World Series title in franchise history.

  • Age: 24 Years Old
  • Games: 12
  • Batting Avg: .320
  • On-Base Pct: .382
  • Slugging Pct: .480
  • Hits: 16
  • Home Runs: 2
  • RBIs: 4
  • Runs: 7
  • Stolen Bases: 8

SS – Alex Rodriguez, Mariners (2000)

arod 560x387

Even though A-Rod has grown a reputation for not being a postseason performer, back in 2000 he was leading the Seattle Mariners to within 2 games from a World Series and he was doing it before he turned 25.

  • Age: 24 Years Old
  • Games: 9
  • Batting Avg: .371
  • On-Base Pct: .421
  • Slugging Pct: .600
  • Hits: 13
  • Home Runs: 2
  • RBIs: 7
  • Runs: 4
  • Walks: 3

3B – George Brett, Royals (1976)


George Brett was one of the greatest 3B to ever live but before he won a World Series in 1985, he was busting his tail to get the Royals there when he was only 23. Although they didn’t make it to the World Series in 1976, he started moving them in the right direction for the future with the young man’s performance that year.

  • Age: 23 Years Old
  • Games: 5
  • Batting Avg: .444
  • On-Base Pct: .476
  • Slugging Pct: .778
  • Hits: 8
  • Home Runs: 1
  • RBIs: 5
  • Runs: 4

LF – Jorge Soler, Cubs (2015)

Jorge Soler 560x421

Of the Chicago Cubs 7 games so far in the 2015 postseason, Jorge Soler has played in 5 of them. He is getting on base a sick amount of times plus he continues to hit for power making him a very dangerous at bat.

  • Age: 23 Years Old
  • Games: 5
  • Batting Avg: .455
  • On-Base Pct: .647
  • Slugging Pct: 1.091
  • Hits: 5
  • Home Runs: 2
  • RBIs: 4
  • Runs: 3
  • Walks: 6

CF – Andruw Jones, Braves (1996)

jones 560x315

Andruw Jones lived up to the hype but he unfortunately never helped the Braves to win the World Series. In 1996, his first season in the league, he did his best especially in Game 7 of the NLCS when he helped them win easily to move on to face the Yankees. Then he exploded in Game 1 of the World Series when he hit 3 for 4, 2 HR, 5 RBI, and 3 R.

  • Age: 19 Years Old
  • Games: 14
  • Batting Avg: .345
  • Hits: 10
  • Home Runs: 3
  • RBIs: 9
  • Runs: 7
  • Walks: 7

RF – Tony Gwynn, Padres (1984)

Tony Gwynn 560x315

Most people remember the great Tony Gwynn for being loyal. The man played his entire Hall of Fame career for the San Diego Padres. It is rare these days for any one player to remain with the same team for an entire career. Even the greats like Joe Montana and Jerry Rice played for other teams before retiring. He stayed true to his team for 20 years.

  • Age: 24 Years Old
  • Games: 10
  • Batting Avg: .316
  • Hits: 12
  • Home Runs: 0
  • RBIs: 3
  • Runs: 7

DH – Derek Jeter, Yankees (1996)

derek jeter yankees feb12 2001 world series getty 560x331

Since we already have a shortstop, we had no choice but to put 22 year old Derek Jeter in as our DH, designated hitter. He was so young back then but even at 22, he was setting the stage for an amazing career in New York.

  • Age: 22 Years Old
  • Games: 15
  • Batting Avg: .361
  • On-Base Pct: .409
  • Slugging Pct: .459
  • Hits: 22
  • Home Runs: 1
  • RBIs: 3
  • Runs: 12
  • Stolen Bases: 3

SP – Christy Mathewson, Giants (1905)

Christy Mathewson 560x442

The New York Giants won the 1905 World Series after finishing 105-48. Christy Mathewson led the pitching rotation which also had three 20 game winners and not a single starter with an ERA over 2.87. Then he erupted in the World Series with 3 Complete Game Shutouts and never giving up a single run.

  • Age: 24 Years Old
  • Games: 3
  • Innings Pitched: 27.0
  • ERA: 0.00
  • Wins: 3
  • Strikeouts: 18
  • Complete Games: 3
  • Shutouts: 3

SP – Josh Beckett, Marlins (2003)

beckett 2014 05 20 560x319

2003 was his third year in the league and Josh Beckett was needed by the Florida Marlins and he showed up. He ended up pitching in 6 games that postseason with a 2.11 ERA. After pitching Game 3 of the World Series on Tuesday, he was called upon to start again on Saturday for a clinching Game 6 and he was sensational on three days rest. He pitched a Complete Game Shutout giving up only 5 hits with 9 Ks. The game was truly the greatest of his career.

  • Age: 23 Years Old
  • Games: 6
  • Innings Pitched: 42.2
  • ERA: 2.11
  • Wins: 2
  • Strikeouts: 47
  • Complete Games: 2
  • Shutouts: 2

SP – Cole Hamels, Phillies (2008)

Cole Hamels 560x389

Numbers aside, Cole Hamels was one of the best pitchers in Philadelphia Phillies history because he did more with less around him than anyone else.

  • Age: 24 Years Old
  • Games: 5
  • Innings Pitched: 35.0
  • ERA: 1.80
  • Wins: 4
  • Strikeouts: 30

SP – John Smoltz, Braves (1991)

smoltz1 560x315

John Smoltz was just a great pitcher. He eventually moved to a closer role, which he also dominated for three seasons until moving back into the rotation and winning 14, 16, and 14 games. Can you think of anyone in the majors that started off a starter and dominated for many years before moving to the bullpen and tearing that up and then finally going back to the starting rotation and continuing right where he left off?

  • Age: 24 Years Old
  • Games: 4
  • Innings Pitched: 29.2
  • ERA: 1.52
  • Wins: 2
  • Strikeouts: 26
  • Complete Games: 1
  • Shutouts: 1

SP – Fernando Valenzuela, Dodgers (1981)

fernando valenzuela 560x373

The 20 year old had his best season of his career in 1981 as well as postseason. During the regular season he finished with 8 shutouts, 11 complete games, a 2.38 ERA, and 180 strikeouts.

  • Age: 20 Years Old
  • Games: 5
  • Innings Pitched: 40.2
  • Wins: 3
  • Strikeouts: 26
  • Complete Games: 2

RP – Francisco Rodriguez, Angels (2002)

Francisco Rodriguez 560x406

After pitching just 5.2 innings during the regular season, the Angels unleashed him in the 2002 playoffs and it was a legendary decision. Not only did he help the Angels beef up their bullpen, he won 5 of the 19 games they played that postseason. It is tied with Randy Johnson for the most wins in a single postseason by any pitcher and he did it before he was legally allowed to buy alcohol.

  • Age: 20 Years Old
  • Games: 11
  • Innings Pitched: 18.2
  • ERA: 1.93
  • Wins: 5
  • Strikeouts: 28
  • Holds: 3

CL – Neftali Feliz, Rangers (2011)

Neftali perez 560x374

During his second consecutive World Series with the Texas Rangers, Neftali Feliz almost helped the Rangers win their first ever title. Even with his dominance in 2010 and 2011, he came in during the 9th inning of Game 6 with a 2 run lead. With 2 on and 2 out, he made a mistake and David Freese hit a game tying 2-run triple for the Cardinals. Outside of that one hit, he was nearly perfect that year.

  • Age: 23 Years Old
  • Games: 11
  • Innings Pitched: 11.1
  • ERA: 2.38
  • Strikeouts: 12
  • Saves: 6

Thomas Delatte

Contributor at Gunaxin
I love writing about things I love, who wouldn't? Any ideas or positive comments, hit me up on Twitter.